Two periods of my adult life stand out as ultimately futile exercises.
The first began the day I picked up Richard Dawkins’s The God Delusion and lasted nearly a decade, ending around 2015 or 2016 when the rot inside New Atheism could no longer be ignored. What had started as a healthy pushback against religious dogma had curdled into smug, reactionary "anti-woke" posturing—a movement far more interested in humiliating believers than improving human lives. I have since apologized to my family for that phase, and I extend the apology to you all.
The second was a more cautious—yet stubbornly obsessive—detour that began during COVID, right after the Democratic establishment closed ranks to impose Joe Biden at the head of the ticket and snuff out the Bernie Sanders movement I had happily been part of. Looking for where genuine left energy might go next, I wandered into the post-2020 "contrarian left" podcast ecosystem: Douglas Lain’s Zero Books*/Diet Soap/Sublation Media, Chris Cutrone’s Platypus Marxism, Briahna Joy Gray’s Bad Faith, and the orbit of Norman Finkelstein.
For four years, I tried to figure out why a universe claiming to carry the mantle of serious Marxism left me feeling so profoundly disaffected. Watching Lain and Cutrone in conversation on Sublation Media was always something akin to taking cod liver oil. It is completely elective; I don’t recommend it for the taste; and it is either going to make you sick or make you stronger, and you won’t know which until you’re feeling yourself armed for battle or retching into the nearest wastebasket.
The nail in the coffin came in early 2024, when I stumbled across Lain and Cutrone dissecting Norman Finkelstein and Mouin Rabbani’s five-hour debate with Benny Morris and the streamer Destiny on Lex Fridman’s show about Israel and Gaza.
For the record, I want an immediate end to Israel’s siege on Gaza and an end to apartheid. Yet I had already been unsatisfied by how leftist media covered the Fridman encounter—cheering Finkelstein’s crotchety "pwning" of an internet debate bro without wrestling with much substance. It captured everything that grates about Finkelstein as a communicator. Even when he is telling vital truths about Palestine, his debates tend to consist of two kernels of historical insight, ten percent academic bullying over technical fouls, and nearly ninety percent relentless assertion of his own unimpeachable authority based on his diligent close readings. It is pure theater for the already convinced—and pure poison for persuading anyone else.
Still, Finkelstein had returned to the cause of his life after October 7, explicitly regretting the years he had spent "giving up on Palestine" to become an adjunct of the Sublation Media anti-woke circuit (a detour that produced his 2023 book I’ll Burn That Bridge When I Get to It!). So when Lain and Cutrone sat down to critique him, the burning question was: what happens when two Sublation Media contrarians collide?
I took the spoonful of cod liver oil to find out—and immediately bet on illness.
Within minutes, Cutrone was dismissing the International Court of Justice’s ruling for South Africa in its genocide case against Israel. Worse, he was favorably comparing Israel’s all-out assault on Gaza to the U.S. atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki—characterizing both as morally neutral military "transactions" designed to force unconditional surrender. In Cutrone’s hyper-theoretical telling, invoking international law or human empathy merely traps the left in "bourgeois" sentimentality.
That was the exact moment the fever broke. Just as New Atheism had mistaken cruelty for rationality, the contrarian left had mistaken cold-blooded abstraction for revolutionary rigor. Whether it was Finkelstein’s clinical, empathy-free takes on abortion or Cutrone reducing 100,000 dead civilians to a state "transaction," the pattern was unmistakable: when performative contrarianism becomes your entire brand, basic human solidarity is the first casualty.
I didn't even need to finish the video. I closed the tab, walked away from the podcast rabbit hole, and went back to basics: caring about actual human beings, practical solidarity, and real-world politics rather than the endless performance of being the smartest, edgiest person in the room.
~~~~~
* Before his hostile ouster by the editorial team he had been hired to replace.






